Can a shemale be too beautiful?

Well I do agree with you. Just not the way to express your point. You could of easily said you prefer androgyny in the trans girls you find attractive.
And the reason you're getting some flack because of your post, is due to the way you phrased it. But you're new to understanding transgender people. So you get some slack from me.

For me. I never liked the so called "perfect look". Tons of makeup, plastic surgery, and what not. I like natural beauty. And yes taking hormones to become what you rightly are is natural in my opinion.
I'm also not attracted to porn stars. Unless I already know them, or they got out of the industry like Bee did.

I also really like femininity and androgyny in women (including trans girls ) and feminine guys.
Though I don't like androgyny in masculine guys. That's just a huge turn off to me.

And like you I'm totally speaking on a visual aspect.

Originally Posted by randolph

Beauty is certainly in the eye of the beholder. As we grow older our view of beauty can change. For an old geezer, a fifty year old women can look gorgeous. For a teenager, a fifty year old women would look ancient.
Also "attractiveness" is not necessarily related to beauty. Somebody may be very attractive for intellect, skills or yes, sexuality and not be a beauty. Of course sexual skills and beauty would be a highly desirable combination.
OK lets throw intellect in there too.

And totally agree with Randolph here. :D