Quote:
Originally Posted by Jenae LaTorque
I also have no problem seeing that you feel there is a big differance between the two cases in the allegory while I see it as a little differance. The way we feel about each and every thing is colored by the associations our mind makes with that particular thing. The man who nearly drowned in a lake has a differant associations in his mind with it than the man who met his wife and true love while boating on it. So, big differance for you, little differance for me, just a matter of perspective then.
One question you haven't addressed is that concerning the possibility of the pirated video leading someone to your site and your subsequant enrichment. So...?
|
Sorry Jenae...
I didn't mean to insinuate that you're lying...only that you really won't fully understand the point of view we as site owners have since you don't 'market' content.
And, actually, what you said was that you'd be... OK with what I proposed. Which was someone taking your content, marketing it as their own, and selling it. Now I notice you've added the caveat that it wouldn't bother you... a lot. And I tell you... the more you saw the site making money off your content, the more that 'wouldn't bother you... a lot' would turn into 'kill those mother-------.'
But... thanks for the free content... typically, I pay between $40-$80 for a photoset but now I can save that cash and just use your wallpapers for an update. I'm sure lots of other site owners would be more than happy to use this free content as well to add content to their sites, especially since they can market as their own. Wow... my photoshop skills just went into overdrive without one single lesson! Me and the Members of my site thank you very much!
And, I really don't want to start bad blood between the two of us. I respect your opinions and you've been great to converse with. But, let me say... again, your choice of allegory is bad. The guy who drowns in the lake has no opinions on the matter. He's dead and therefore has no perspective. If he were to survive, who knows... it may be his favorite lake and he may still love it. People who have been savagely brutalized by animals still love them. But, that's besides the point...to answer your question...
THE HARM that is done with a whole video being illegally posted FAR outweighs the cost benefits of the VERY FEW who will join a site after viewing it. I don't think there is ANY site owner who would deny that. Find me one and I'll either show you someone who has no financial investment into the site or has a very poorly run business record, i.e. - he's not paying taxes and etc... which, btw... I do. I run a legitimate business. Registered. Pay taxes. Pay local taxes. Do my civic duties. Anyway...
In THAT case, you allegory would be good. A bakery may as well give out free loaves of bread in the hopes that someone will like it enough to come back and buy one. Not in a million years. There will be the one or two out of a thousand who have a moral inclination to do so but the VAST and OVERWHELMING majority would definitely not. It's human nature. If you see FREE on one site and $10.00 on the other for the same item... what are you going to choose.
In the case of torrent sites, if someone doesn't find the content he is looking for, he'll most likely keep searching the site until he does... NOT go directly to the site where the content originated. People who download content illegally from a site often have other consequences for the site owner that are hard to quantify. They usually use some sort of BOT to download multiple videos at once which kills bandwidth and can render the site unusable for other members. Those members in turn get frustrated and quit their memberships. Thus, they are not only taking content with the intention of deliberately spreading it, they are also cost the site other members who would have stayed. And yes, this IS from personal and direct experience. Most sites now implement some sort of program that will defeat multiple downloads at one time for this very purpose but many smaller sites simply can not afford to implement these programs.
C'mon.. let's be realistic. You're trying to justify something you don't really care that much about because it doesn't affect you. It affects me personally and I have a stake in it.
All I'm saying at the start of this whole thread is that if you claim to really enjoy a particular model or site, join it for a month and help support the industry instead of getting your rocks off for free on someone else's dime.