Dany De Castro

[sosed]

I have a question about Dany de Castro. In some internet sites, there are claims, that Dany is not MtF transsexual, but feminine gay male. I'm not here to judge her in any way, because she is only what she feels she is. I would like to ask, if Dany anytime explain, what she feel inside and if she see herself as male or female. That explain would denied wrong claims and make her status more clear. What ever her answer is, she is still a beauty and I still like her.

[smc]

Originally Posted by sosed

I have a question about Dany de Castro. In some internet sites, there are claims, that Dany is not MtF transsexual, but feminine gay male. I'm not here to judge her in any way, because she is only what she feels she is. I would like to ask, if Dany anytime explain, what she feel inside and if she see herself as male or female. That explain would denied wrong claims and make her status more clear. What ever her answer is, she is still a beauty and I still like her.

What "feminine gay male" has breast implants? Seriously?! If I were Dany and read what you posted, I'd be insulted. And with all due respect, why she would feel she needs to "explain" herself to you is beyond my comprehension.

[spacecase9128]

If I recall she is from Brazil, to me if or when I learn Spanish, it would be great to meet Dany.

[sosed]

Why to explain to me? I all the time use term she. I'm not claiming she is male. I just wonder, why that kind of claims appear. Where are the borders between one side and the other. I said she is, what she feel she is. The only question is, if she in past said, what she feel she is, than why that kind of claims happened to claim she is something, what she is not.

[smc]

Originally Posted by sosed

Why to explain to me? I all the time use term she. I'm not claiming she is male. I just wonder, why that kind of claims appear. Where are the borders between one side and the other. I said she is, what she feel she is. The only question is, if she in past said, what she feel she is, than why that kind of claims happened to claim she is something, what she is not.

I stand by what I wrote about your previous post, and I did not attribute to you a claim that she is "male."

To ask her "what she feel she is," given what you can see before your very eyes (the part of my post you simply ignored in your response) is, as I wrote earlier, insulting. I have absolutely no doubt that she would see it that way, just as do I.

[sosed]

In those sites any opposition, who said the same as you, about breast implants, were categorically dismissed as that breast implants are not proving, that someone is MtF transexual, but that it is about personality, not implants. There are a lot of different claims, which make me confusing and that is why I ask where are borders between those two sides. But unfortunately no one is willing to discuss about those questions. For me, Dany is female and that is why I use term she.

[smc]

Originally Posted by sosed

In those sites any opposition, who said the same as you, about breast implants, were categorically dismissed as that breast implants are not proving, that someone is MtF transexual, but that it is about personality, not implants. There are a lot of different claims, which make me confusing and that is why I ask where are borders between those two sides. But unfortunately no one is willing to discuss about those questions. For me, Dany is female and that is why I use term she.

You really don't get why your question is so insulting. If you want to have a general discussion about this topic, post something in the "Chat About Shemales" section. There are numerous threads where these sorts of topics -- such as what "proves" one is MTF transsexual -- are discussed. There you will find the views of our MTF members.

But here, in the "Freebies" section, in a thread devoted to Dany de Castro, you choose to bring up these claims and deign to ask Dany -- as if she is a member here (which she is not, at least not that we know of) -- essentially to defend herself against haters who would demean her and belittle her by claim she is nothing but a "feminine gay male." You made it about Dany by posting it here. You are thus complicit by advancing the cause of the haters. That is what I meant with my initial response, and I continue to stand by it as you dig your hole deeper.

[sosed]

I agree, that this question could be send to different section. I chose Dany's tread, because she was mentioned there and I don't understand, why she would be different to other tgirls. I understand, that there are people who don't like her, but this question could be a larger problem, because it could happened to any MtF transexual. That is why I think it could be fine to discuss where are borders between those two sides to avoid confusion, which bring only more hate.